Discussions among players on the online platform Reddit often focus on identifying the most effective armaments in Elden Ring that scale primarily with the Strength stat. These weapons, prized for their high damage output and ability to stagger enemies, are a popular choice for builds emphasizing raw power. A common example is seeking recommendations for a weapon capable of easily defeating a specific boss or traversing a challenging area, based on player experiences shared within the Elden Ring subreddit.
The importance of these discussions stems from the vast array of weapons available in the game, each with unique attributes and scaling properties. Determining the optimal Strength weapon can significantly enhance a player’s combat effectiveness, contributing to a more enjoyable and successful playthrough. The platform provides a space for the community to pool knowledge, compare strategies, and offer guidance, especially valuable given the game’s inherent difficulty and opaque mechanics. Historically, such collaborative efforts have been essential for players navigating complex game systems.
The following sections will delve into several highly-regarded armaments for Strength-focused builds in Elden Ring, drawing upon community consensus and in-game performance data. Specific examples, moveset analysis, and recommended Ashes of War will be provided to aid in weapon selection. Considerations for early, mid, and late-game options will also be discussed.
1. Weapon scaling values
Weapon scaling values in Elden Ring dictate how effectively a weapon’s attack power increases with corresponding stat investments, and are pivotal in determining the “best strength weapons”. Higher scaling generally indicates a greater return on stat points, thus impacting damage output potential. Discussions within the Elden Ring subreddit often revolve around identifying weapons with optimal Strength scaling.
-
Scaling Grades and Damage Output
Scaling is represented by grades ranging from S (best) to E (worst), alongside a “no scaling” (-) designation. A weapon with ‘S’ scaling in Strength will see a significantly larger damage increase per point invested in Strength compared to a weapon with ‘D’ scaling. The total damage output a weapon can achieve at high Strength levels is often a deciding factor in community assessments of its effectiveness.
-
Impact on Build Optimization
Efficient utilization of stat points is crucial for optimizing a character build. Weapons with superior Strength scaling enable players to allocate fewer points to other stats, allowing for investment in survivability or secondary damage stats, such as Endurance for heavier armor. This optimization is a frequent topic on Reddit, with players sharing strategies for maximizing damage while maintaining effective defensive capabilities.
-
Influence on Weapon Selection
When choosing a Strength weapon, scaling values are typically considered alongside other factors such as base damage, weapon skills, and moveset. A weapon with lower base damage but superior scaling can surpass a weapon with high base damage but poor scaling at higher stat levels. Discussions within the community often involve comparing various weapon options at different Strength levels to determine the optimal choice for a particular stage of the game.
-
Consideration of Infusion and Ashes of War
The ability to infuse a weapon with Ashes of War and modify its scaling is a vital element. Some infusions, like Heavy, will improve Strength scaling, further enhancing a weapon’s effectiveness for Strength builds. The community actively explores combinations of weapons and infusions to achieve maximum damage potential, sharing results and insights on Reddit forums.
In conclusion, scaling values are a central component of any evaluation of Strength weapons within the Elden Ring community. They directly impact damage potential, build optimization, and overall weapon effectiveness, leading to extensive discussions and comparisons on platforms such as Reddit. The interaction between base damage, scaling grade, infusion options, and stat investment is a primary concern when determining which weapons are considered the “best” for Strength-focused builds.
2. Damage Type Efficacy
Damage type efficacy is a critical consideration in evaluating the performance of Strength weapons in Elden Ring, influencing community discussions and rankings. Understanding how different damage types interact with enemy defenses directly informs the selection of optimal armaments, a recurring theme in online forums such as Reddit.
-
Physical Damage Types and Enemy Armor
Physical damage is divided into Standard, Strike, Slash, and Pierce. Each damage type interacts differently with enemy armor values. For instance, heavily armored enemies may exhibit higher resistance to Slash and Pierce damage, rendering Strike weapons more effective. Community discussions on Reddit often dissect enemy armor profiles and recommend corresponding Strength weapons accordingly. An example is recommending a colossal weapon with Strike damage against heavily armored Crucible Knights.
-
Elemental Damage Infusions and Vulnerabilities
Strength weapons can be infused with elemental damage types such as Fire, Lightning, Magic, and Holy. Many enemies possess elemental weaknesses that can be exploited to significantly increase damage output. Discussions on Reddit explore the synergistic combinations of Strength scaling and elemental infusions, highlighting weapons that, when properly infused, excel against specific bosses or regions. For example, utilizing a Fire-infused Strength weapon against a frost-based enemy.
-
Critical Hit Damage and Weapon Attributes
Certain Strength weapons possess inherent critical hit bonuses, enhancing their effectiveness in situations where enemies are vulnerable to critical attacks. These weapons are often favored for their ability to deliver substantial burst damage, particularly in PvE scenarios. Reddit threads frequently analyze weapon critical values, comparing their performance during guard breaks or backstabs. An example would be comparing daggers with higher critical values to larger Strength weapons during a riposte.
-
Hidden Damage Modifiers and Enemy Types
Elden Ring incorporates hidden damage modifiers that affect weapon performance against specific enemy types. Some enemies, such as those with stony exteriors, may exhibit increased vulnerability to certain damage types. The community actively investigates these hidden modifiers, sharing discoveries and strategies on Reddit. For instance, experimentation may reveal that a seemingly ineffective Strength weapon proves unexpectedly potent against a particular boss due to an undocumented damage bonus.
In conclusion, damage type efficacy is an integral aspect of Strength weapon evaluation in Elden Ring. The Reddit community’s focus on analyzing enemy defenses, elemental vulnerabilities, critical hit potential, and hidden damage modifiers underscores the importance of understanding these mechanics for optimizing Strength-based builds. These discussions collectively shape the perception of “best” Strength weapons, emphasizing the need for informed decision-making based on comprehensive damage type considerations.
3. Move set versatility
Move set versatility is a primary determinant of a Strength weapon’s overall effectiveness and, consequently, its ranking within community discussions on platforms such as Reddit. The ability to adapt to diverse combat scenarios dictates a weapon’s utility, affecting both player survivability and damage output. A weapon lacking in versatile attacks may be limited in its application, regardless of its raw damage potential, thus impacting its perceived value among players.
The correlation between move set versatility and Strength weapon efficacy is evident in player evaluations. For example, colossal swords, known for their high damage, may be criticized for their slow attack speed and limited moves against agile opponents. Conversely, greatswords, offering a balance of speed, range, and diverse attacks (thrusts, sweeps, overhead slams), often receive higher praise due to their adaptability. This translates to practical significance; a versatile move set enables efficient management of both individual enemies and groups, improving survivability and allowing for exploitation of enemy weaknesses. Discussions frequently highlight how specific move set options such as charged heavy attacks for staggering, rolling attacks for repositioning, or jumping attacks for aerial engagement contribute to a Strength weapon’s overall appeal.
The influence of move set versatility on weapon preference is further exemplified by the community’s response to unique weapon skills. A Strength weapon equipped with a powerful or adaptable skill can compensate for limitations in its base move set. Furthermore, the interaction between a weapon’s move set and its ability to stagger enemies also impacts its popularity among Strength builds. Weapons with attacks that consistently interrupt enemy actions are highly valued, especially in boss encounters. Consequently, move set versatility is an essential component of community assessments, directly influencing the designation of “best strength weapons” and contributing to the ongoing dialogue on platforms like Reddit.
4. Ash of War compatibility
Ash of War compatibility significantly influences the perceived value of Strength weapons within the Elden Ring community, as evidenced by discussions on platforms like Reddit. A weapon’s potential is not solely determined by its base stats or scaling but is heavily augmented by its capacity to accept and effectively utilize Ashes of War. This compatibility allows players to customize weapon skills and damage types, providing strategic flexibility and adaptation to various combat scenarios. A Strength weapon inherently limited by its move set or damage profile can be transformed into a versatile tool through the application of a suitable Ash of War. This capability is a crucial factor in determining whether a weapon is considered among the best for Strength-focused builds. For instance, a colossal sword, known for its slow attack speed, might benefit significantly from an Ash of War that provides a quick, gap-closing attack, addressing a key weakness. Similarly, a Strength weapon dealing purely physical damage can gain access to elemental damage types, exploiting enemy vulnerabilities.
The community’s assessment of Ash of War compatibility extends beyond mere application, encompassing an evaluation of scaling. Strength weapons that exhibit strong scaling with the Heavy infusion, often applied via Ashes of War, are particularly valued. This infusion enhances Strength scaling, maximizing damage output and synergizing with a player’s stat investment. The practical application of this understanding involves careful consideration of both the Ash of War’s skill and its impact on weapon scaling. Some Ashes of War may offer powerful skills but negatively affect Strength scaling, rendering them less desirable for dedicated Strength builds. Conversely, Ashes of War that provide a relevant skill and improve Strength scaling are highly sought after. Examples include applying the “Lion’s Claw” Ash of War to a greatsword, providing a powerful leaping attack while maintaining excellent Strength scaling or the “Royal Knight’s Resolve” that buffs the next attack’s damage by a significant amount. These examples demonstrate the importance of synergistic pairings between weapons and Ashes of War.
In conclusion, Ash of War compatibility is an indispensable consideration when evaluating Strength weapons in Elden Ring. The capacity to customize weapon skills and damage types, coupled with the potential to enhance Strength scaling through infusions, significantly impacts a weapon’s effectiveness and its standing within the community. Understanding this connection is crucial for optimizing Strength-based builds and maximizing combat potential. The ongoing discussions on Reddit highlight the community’s recognition of Ash of War compatibility as a defining characteristic of the “best strength weapons elden ring.”
5. Stat investment required
The correlation between required stat investment and the designation of “best strength weapons elden ring reddit” is significant. Community discussions consistently address the trade-off between a weapon’s performance and the stat points needed to wield it effectively. Weapons demanding high Strength, and potentially other stats like Dexterity or Faith for secondary scaling, may be excluded from the ‘best’ category if the investment outweighs the benefits for a given build archetype. For instance, a weapon with exceptional damage output but requiring 50 Strength may be deemed less desirable than a weapon with slightly lower damage needing only 40 Strength, allowing for more points to be allocated to Vitality or Endurance. A low-level build, for example, prioritizing survivability and early game effectiveness will favor weapons with minimal stat requirements.
Further analysis reveals the importance of considering stat requirements in the context of a player’s overall progression strategy. Early-game stat investment may prioritize meeting the minimum requirements for a weapon that provides a substantial power boost, even if its long-term scaling is less optimal. Examples include prioritizing the Greatsword early on, accepting lower overall stats in other areas to wield it. Conversely, late-game builds with ample stat points may favor weapons with higher requirements that offer superior scaling and damage potential at maximum Strength. The community discussions often incorporate detailed comparisons of weapon performance at various stat levels, providing insights into the optimal investment strategy for each weapon.
In summary, stat investment required is a pivotal component in community assessments of Strength weapons in Elden Ring. The balance between stat demands, damage output, and overall build efficiency dictates weapon preference. Understanding this relationship enables players to make informed decisions, optimizing their characters for specific playstyles and progression milestones. Ignoring this aspect leads to inefficient builds and suboptimal combat performance. The ongoing discussions within the Elden Ring subreddit underscore the importance of considering stat requirements when determining the “best strength weapons” for individual needs.
6. Weapon weight factor
The weapon weight factor, a core mechanic in Elden Ring, significantly influences player mobility and stamina management, impacting the selection process for Strength weapons. Discussions on online platforms, such as Reddit, frequently weigh the benefits of high-damage armaments against their encumbrance, shaping community perception of the “best strength weapons”.
-
Encumbrance Thresholds and Movement Speed
Elden Ring employs an encumbrance system, where character mobility is directly affected by the weight of equipped gear. Exceeding certain thresholds results in reduced movement speed, shorter roll distance, and diminished iframes during dodge maneuvers. Strength weapons, known for their high damage potential, often come with considerable weight. The choice between a lighter, faster weapon and a heavier, more powerful one is a constant topic on Reddit, with players debating the optimal balance between damage output and mobility.
-
Stamina Consumption and Weapon Weight
Heavier weapons typically consume more stamina per attack and block. This increased stamina cost affects the frequency and duration of combat actions. A Strength weapon with high weight may limit a player’s ability to chain attacks or maintain a defensive stance. The Elden Ring subreddit often features discussions on stamina management strategies, with players sharing builds that prioritize Endurance to mitigate the drawbacks of heavy weapons. Considerations such as stamina recovery rate and talismans that reduce stamina consumption are also frequently examined.
-
Poise Damage and Stagger Potential
While heavier weapons impose a mobility penalty, they often deliver greater poise damage, increasing the likelihood of staggering enemies. This stagger potential can create openings for critical attacks or prevent enemies from executing their own attacks. Strength weapons are frequently chosen for their ability to break enemy poise, making them effective against heavily armored foes. However, players must weigh the advantages of poise damage against the limitations imposed by the weapon’s weight.
-
Armor Optimization and Load Management
Managing equipment load involves optimizing armor choices to maximize defense without exceeding encumbrance thresholds. Players often sacrifice heavier armor pieces to maintain a medium or light load, allowing for greater mobility. Discussions on Reddit explore various armor combinations and talismans that increase equipment load capacity, enabling players to wield heavier Strength weapons without compromising mobility. This optimization process is crucial for creating viable Strength builds that balance offense and defense.
In summary, the weapon weight factor is an integral consideration in evaluating Strength weapons in Elden Ring. The interplay between mobility, stamina consumption, poise damage, and armor optimization directly affects a weapon’s overall effectiveness and its standing within the community. The debates on Reddit highlight the need for a nuanced understanding of the encumbrance system when determining the “best strength weapons”, emphasizing the importance of striking a balance between raw power and tactical maneuverability.
7. Availability timing
The accessibility of Strength weapons at various stages of Elden Ring significantly influences their perceived value and the frequency with which they are discussed on platforms like Reddit. A weapon’s raw power is secondary to its utility if it cannot be obtained until late in the game. Therefore, availability timing becomes a critical factor in determining what the community considers the “best strength weapons elden ring reddit”, often prioritizing those obtainable earlier in the playthrough.
-
Early Game Accessibility and Build Viability
Weapons accessible in the early game provide immediate benefits to Strength-focused builds, shaping the player’s experience from the outset. The ease with which these weapons can be acquired often leads to their popularity and frequent recommendation on Reddit. Examples include the Greatsword, obtainable relatively early and capable of carrying players through a significant portion of the game. Its availability and effectiveness make it a common topic of discussion and a frequent choice for new Strength builds.
-
Mid-Game Progression and Weapon Transition
As players progress, the availability of new weapons impacts their choices and build optimization. Mid-game weapons provide opportunities for transition, potentially replacing early-game options that may become less effective. Discussions on Reddit often involve comparisons between early-game and mid-game Strength weapons, weighing their relative strengths and weaknesses. This transition period is crucial, and weapons that facilitate smooth progression are highly valued.
-
Late-Game Power and Endgame Viability
Late-game Strength weapons represent the pinnacle of power, offering the highest damage potential and unique combat capabilities. However, their late availability means they may not be suitable for all players, particularly those who prefer to experiment with different builds throughout the game. While these weapons are powerful, their impact on the overall playthrough is limited compared to weapons available earlier. This impacts their perception on Reddit, where effectiveness throughout the entire game is often prioritized.
-
Impact on Playthrough Strategy and Community Recommendations
Availability timing influences the overall playthrough strategy, guiding players toward specific areas and bosses to acquire desired weapons. Community recommendations on Reddit often consider this factor, suggesting optimal routes and strategies for obtaining key Strength weapons at various stages of the game. This collaborative effort ensures that players can access the best possible armaments based on their current progression and playstyle.
In conclusion, availability timing is an essential consideration when evaluating Strength weapons in Elden Ring. A weapon’s accessibility throughout the game directly influences its utility, popularity, and frequency of discussion on platforms like Reddit. The community’s focus on early, mid, and late-game options highlights the importance of balancing raw power with practical availability when determining the “best strength weapons elden ring reddit”.
8. Community tier lists
Community tier lists, frequently found on platforms such as Reddit, serve as aggregated opinions reflecting the perceived effectiveness of Strength weapons in Elden Ring. These lists, often categorized from “S” (best) to “D” or “F” (worst), represent a synthesis of player experiences, statistical data, and theoretical analyses. The formation of these tiers is not arbitrary; they emerge from extensive discussions, practical application within the game, and comparative evaluations. For example, a weapon consistently ranked highly on multiple community tier lists likely possesses a combination of high damage output, versatile move set, and favorable scaling with Strength. Conversely, weapons relegated to lower tiers typically suffer from limitations in one or more of these areas. The existence of these tier lists directly influences the perception of which Strength weapons are considered “best,” shaping player choices and build strategies.
The importance of community tier lists lies in their ability to distill complex information into an easily digestible format. A player seeking guidance on selecting a Strength weapon can quickly consult these lists, gaining a general understanding of the relative strengths and weaknesses of various options. However, it is crucial to recognize that tier lists are not definitive. Individual playstyles, build configurations, and personal preferences can significantly impact weapon effectiveness. For example, a player specializing in jump attacks may find a weapon deemed “B tier” on a general list to be highly effective, owing to its strong jumping attack damage. Furthermore, community tier lists evolve over time, reflecting balance changes implemented by the game developers and the discovery of new strategies by the player base. Therefore, they should be viewed as a starting point for exploration rather than an absolute authority.
In conclusion, community tier lists represent a valuable resource for players seeking to identify effective Strength weapons in Elden Ring. While these lists are not without limitations, they provide a framework for understanding the relative strengths and weaknesses of various options, informed by the collective experience of the player community. Their existence directly shapes the perception of which weapons are considered “best”, influencing player choices and build strategies. However, players are encouraged to critically evaluate tier list recommendations, considering their own playstyles and preferences. The dynamic nature of these lists underscores the importance of staying informed and adapting to evolving game mechanics.
9. Player feedback consensus
Player feedback consensus is paramount in shaping the discourse surrounding optimal Strength armaments within Elden Ring, particularly within online communities such as Reddit. These platforms serve as crucibles where individual experiences coalesce into collective assessments, directly influencing perceptions of weapon effectiveness.
-
Anecdotal Evidence and Empirical Verification
Player anecdotes often provide initial assessments of weapon performance, detailing subjective experiences in combat scenarios. These accounts, while valuable, undergo scrutiny through empirical verification. Data-driven analyses, such as damage calculations and speed tests, complement anecdotal evidence, leading to a more objective consensus. For example, a player’s claim that a certain weapon is highly effective against a specific boss prompts further investigation by others, leading to a shared understanding of its strengths and weaknesses.
-
Comparative Analysis and Weapon Ranking
Player feedback frequently involves comparative analysis, pitting different Strength weapons against one another in various contexts. These comparisons consider factors such as damage output, move set versatility, and Ash of War compatibility. Over time, these analyses contribute to informal weapon rankings, guiding players toward options deemed most effective. A weapon consistently praised for its poise-breaking capabilities, for instance, may rise in the community’s estimation, impacting its representation on tier lists and build guides.
-
Addressing Misconceptions and Refining Knowledge
Player feedback is instrumental in identifying and correcting misconceptions surrounding Strength weapons. Initial impressions may be based on incomplete information or biased testing methodologies. Through collaborative investigation and rigorous analysis, the community refines its understanding of weapon mechanics. For example, a weapon initially perceived as underpowered may be reevaluated as players discover optimal scaling paths or advantageous skill combinations, altering the consensus regarding its viability.
-
Adapting to Game Updates and Balance Changes
Elden Ring is subject to periodic updates, which may introduce balance changes affecting weapon performance. Player feedback is crucial in assessing the impact of these changes and adapting community knowledge accordingly. A Strength weapon previously considered top-tier may lose favor if its damage output is reduced, prompting players to explore alternative options. The community’s responsiveness to these changes ensures that weapon recommendations remain relevant and accurate.
In conclusion, player feedback consensus acts as a dynamic filter, shaping the collective understanding of Strength weapon effectiveness within Elden Ring. Through a combination of anecdotal evidence, empirical verification, comparative analysis, and adaptation to game updates, the community generates a nuanced perspective that directly influences perceptions of which armaments are deemed “best” on platforms like Reddit. The iterative nature of this process ensures that weapon recommendations reflect the most current and accurate information available.
Frequently Asked Questions about Strength Weapons in Elden Ring
This section addresses commonly raised questions regarding Strength-based weaponry in Elden Ring, drawing upon discussions and consensus within the Reddit community. The aim is to provide clear, factual answers to aid in informed weapon selection.
Question 1: What constitutes a “Strength weapon” in Elden Ring?
A Strength weapon primarily scales with the Strength stat, meaning its attack power increases significantly as the Strength stat is raised. These weapons often feature high base damage and are capable of inflicting substantial poise damage.
Question 2: Are Strength weapons viable for all character builds?
While Strength weapons excel in builds focused on raw physical damage, they may require significant stat investment, potentially limiting versatility in hybrid builds. Viability depends on optimizing stat allocation and weapon selection to complement the overall build strategy.
Question 3: How does weapon weight impact Strength weapon selection?
Heavier Strength weapons impose movement penalties due to increased encumbrance. This necessitates careful management of equipment load, potentially requiring investment in Endurance or the use of equipment load-enhancing talismans.
Question 4: What is the significance of Ash of War compatibility for Strength weapons?
Ashes of War allow for customization of weapon skills and damage types, significantly enhancing versatility. Strength weapons that readily accept and scale well with various Ashes of War are generally considered more valuable.
Question 5: How do damage types (Strike, Slash, Pierce) affect Strength weapon effectiveness?
Different enemy types exhibit varying resistances to physical damage types. Understanding these vulnerabilities and selecting Strength weapons with appropriate damage types is crucial for maximizing damage output.
Question 6: Are there recommended Strength weapons for early, mid, and late-game progression?
Early-game options often prioritize accessibility and immediate power, while mid-game and late-game choices focus on scaling and specialized combat capabilities. Community resources, such as tier lists and build guides, provide specific recommendations for each stage of the game.
In summary, informed Strength weapon selection requires consideration of scaling, weight, Ash of War compatibility, damage types, and availability throughout the game. Player feedback and community resources offer valuable insights to aid in this process.
The following section will explore effective strategies for utilizing Strength weapons in various combat scenarios.
Tips for Mastering Strength Weapons in Elden Ring
This section provides actionable strategies for effectively wielding Strength-based armaments in Elden Ring. These tips are based on community consensus and practical application, emphasizing tactical awareness and optimized combat techniques.
Tip 1: Prioritize Poise Damage. Strength weapons excel at inflicting poise damage, disrupting enemy attacks and creating opportunities for critical strikes. Focus on attacks that maximize poise damage output, such as charged heavy attacks and jump attacks.
Tip 2: Manage Stamina Effectively. Strength weapons often consume significant stamina. Careful management of stamina is essential to avoid vulnerability during combat. Utilize talismans and armor that enhance stamina recovery or reduce stamina consumption.
Tip 3: Optimize Equipment Load for Mobility. Maintain a medium or light equipment load to ensure optimal movement speed and dodge roll distance. Experiment with different armor combinations and talismans to balance defense and mobility.
Tip 4: Exploit Enemy Weaknesses. Understand enemy vulnerabilities to different damage types. Infuse Strength weapons with appropriate elemental or status effects to maximize damage output against specific foes.
Tip 5: Utilize Weapon Skills Strategically. Weapon skills provide unique combat options and can compensate for limitations in a weapon’s base move set. Experiment with different Ashes of War to find skills that complement your playstyle and address specific combat challenges.
Tip 6: Master Spacing and Timing. Strength weapons often have slower attack speeds. Precise spacing and timing are crucial for landing attacks and avoiding enemy counters. Practice anticipating enemy movements and utilizing roll attacks to close the distance.
Effective utilization of Strength weapons requires a nuanced understanding of combat mechanics, enemy vulnerabilities, and stat optimization. Mastering these strategies will significantly enhance combat effectiveness and overall gameplay experience.
The following section will conclude this exploration of Strength weapons in Elden Ring, summarizing key findings and offering final recommendations.
Conclusion
The discourse surrounding “best strength weapons elden ring reddit” reveals the complex interplay of factors influencing weapon selection. Scaling values, damage type efficacy, move set versatility, Ash of War compatibility, stat investment, weapon weight, availability timing, community tier lists, and player feedback all contribute to the perceived effectiveness of any given armament. No single weapon universally reigns supreme; optimal choices are contingent upon individual playstyles, build configurations, and progression milestones.
The collective wisdom of the community serves as a valuable resource, but ultimate weapon selection remains a personal endeavor. Continuous experimentation, adaptation to evolving game mechanics, and a critical assessment of individual needs will yield the most rewarding results. The ongoing dialogue surrounding Strength weapons ensures a dynamic understanding of their potential, fostering a deeper engagement with the game’s combat systems.
