The phrase “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” represents a confluence of discussion surrounding the upcoming Dragon Age: The Veilguard video game, perceived “woke” elements (referring to the inclusion of diverse characters or narratives), and the related reactions and debates within the Reddit community. The combination serves as shorthand for analyzing the game’s portrayal of inclusivity and how that portrayal is being received, particularly on the Reddit platform. It encapsulates discussions about character design, narrative choices, and their alignment with contemporary social values, often framed in terms of cultural representation.
The significance of this topic lies in the broader discourse surrounding representation in media and its impact on audience perception. Understanding this allows for examining how developers navigate the balance between artistic vision, inclusivity, and potential backlash from certain segments of the gaming community. Historically, discussions on similar themes have revealed underlying tensions related to identity, political correctness, and the evolving expectations placed upon entertainment products to reflect societal diversity. The benefit of analyzing these types of discussions lies in understanding the various perspectives involved, improving communication, and developing more inclusive and engaging entertainment experiences for a wider audience.
This analysis necessitates exploring specific character designs within Dragon Age: The Veilguard, scrutinizing the narrative choices made by BioWare, and examining the range of reactions, from supportive to critical, expressed on various Reddit subforums dedicated to the game and related topics. Furthermore, it requires understanding the language and rhetoric used in these discussions, identifying the common arguments and counter-arguments, and ultimately, assessing the overall impact of this discourse on the game’s perception and potential success.
1. Character Diversity
Character diversity within Dragon Age: The Veilguard serves as a primary catalyst for the “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” discourse. The inclusion of characters from various ethnic backgrounds, gender identities, sexual orientations, and body types directly fuels discussions concerning representation and perceived political agendas within the game’s design. The degree to which these characters’ identities are integrated into the narrative, versus being perceived as tokenistic, often dictates the tone of the conversation on platforms like Reddit. For example, if a character’s race is integral to their backstory and interactions, it might be viewed more favorably than if it appears as a superficial addition intended solely for representation points.
The importance of character diversity within this context stems from the broader societal demand for inclusivity and accurate representation in media. A failure to represent diverse characters authentically can lead to criticisms of perpetuating harmful stereotypes or misrepresenting marginalized communities. Conversely, a well-executed diverse cast can contribute to a more immersive and engaging gaming experience for a wider audience. The “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” conversations often revolve around evaluating whether BioWare has succeeded in this balancing act. Discussions might involve examining the depth of character backstories, the roles they play within the central narrative, and the overall impact of their inclusion on the game’s themes and messages.
In essence, the presence and portrayal of diverse characters in Dragon Age: The Veilguard function as the primary driver for the “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” phenomenon. The intensity and nature of the online discussions directly reflect how users perceive the authenticity, integration, and impact of this diversity within the game’s world and narrative. Understanding this connection is crucial for both developers, who must navigate the complex terrain of representation, and players, who engage in the ongoing conversation about what constitutes meaningful and effective diversity in video games. The discourse highlights the challenges involved in satisfying a diverse audience with varied expectations and sensitivities regarding representation in entertainment.
2. Narrative Inclusivity
Narrative inclusivity, referring to the incorporation of diverse perspectives, themes, and social issues into the storyline of Dragon Age: The Veilguard, directly impacts the “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” discourse. The inclusion of LGBTQ+ relationships, discussions of systemic inequality, or storylines addressing political and social injustices within the game’s world can trigger intense reactions and discussions on Reddit. The perceived alignment of these narrative elements with contemporary social justice movements frequently leads to the application of the term “woke” and fuels debates regarding the appropriateness of such themes in a fantasy setting. Cause and effect are evident: increased narrative inclusivity results in heightened scrutiny and amplified opinions, both positive and negative, within the Reddit community.
The importance of narrative inclusivity within this context stems from its potential to offer richer and more meaningful gaming experiences. When narratives reflect a broader range of human experiences and perspectives, they can resonate with a wider audience and encourage players to engage with complex social issues in a safe and engaging environment. For example, if Dragon Age: The Veilguard presents a nuanced portrayal of a marginalized group facing discrimination, it can spark meaningful dialogue among players about real-world issues. Conversely, if such themes are perceived as heavy-handed, preachy, or inauthentic, it can lead to criticism and accusations of virtue signaling. The practical significance of understanding this dynamic lies in BioWare’s ability to craft narratives that are both engaging and sensitive to the diverse values and expectations of its player base. Misjudging the audience’s reception can directly impact the game’s commercial success and overall reputation.
In conclusion, narrative inclusivity serves as a crucial element driving the “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” phenomenon. The way BioWare integrates diverse themes and perspectives into the storyline directly influences the nature and intensity of online discussions. Understanding this connection is essential for navigating the complex landscape of contemporary game development, where developers must balance artistic vision, social responsibility, and audience expectations. Successfully incorporating narrative inclusivity can enhance the game’s value and impact; however, mishandling it can lead to backlash and damage to the game’s reception. The online reaction serves as a real-time barometer of public sentiment regarding these issues.
3. Reddit Reactions
Reddit reactions are integral to the phenomenon encapsulated by “dragon age veilguard woke reddit.” The platform serves as a central hub for discussion, debate, and critique surrounding the game, its characters, and its narrative choices, particularly concerning perceived “woke” elements. The reactions expressed on Reddit directly shape the perception and reception of Dragon Age: The Veilguard within the wider gaming community and beyond.
-
Subreddit Dynamics
Different subreddits host varying viewpoints. Some forums, like the official Dragon Age subreddit, may exhibit a more moderate or supportive stance. Others, dedicated to gaming criticism or those with specific political alignments, may express more overtly critical opinions. Understanding the dynamics within each subreddit is crucial for gauging the spectrum of reactions. For example, one subreddit might focus on positive aspects of inclusivity, while another dissects perceived flaws in representation.
-
Upvote/Downvote Systems
The upvote/downvote system acts as a real-time indicator of community sentiment. Comments and posts that align with the prevailing opinion within a specific subreddit tend to rise to the top, while dissenting voices are often suppressed. This creates echo chambers where certain viewpoints are amplified, potentially skewing the overall perception of player opinion. A highly upvoted comment criticizing character design, for instance, can reinforce negative sentiment, even if other players hold differing views.
-
Meme Culture and Humor
Reddits meme culture often plays a significant role in shaping the narrative. Humorous depictions, whether supportive or critical, can quickly spread and influence public perception. A meme mocking a specific character trait or plot point, even if exaggerated, can contribute to a broader negative perception. Conversely, memes celebrating inclusive elements can garner support and normalize diverse representation.
-
Developer Engagement
To a varying degree, developers may monitor and engage with Reddit discussions. This interaction can range from simply observing community sentiment to actively responding to criticism or feedback. Developer responses can either defuse tensions or exacerbate existing conflicts, depending on their approach and the tone of their communication. A perceived dismissal of community concerns, for instance, can fuel further negative reactions.
The collective reactions on Reddit significantly contribute to the ongoing dialogue surrounding “dragon age veilguard woke reddit.” They influence the public perception of the game, potentially affecting its commercial success and shaping future development decisions. The platform serves as a crucial battleground for shaping the narrative and determining the perceived value of inclusivity and representation within the Dragon Age franchise.
4. “Woke” Accusations
The proliferation of “woke” accusations forms a significant component of the “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” discourse. These accusations, frequently leveled against Dragon Age: The Veilguard, center around the perceived overemphasis on social justice themes, diverse character representation, and narratives that align with progressive political ideologies. The cause of these accusations often stems from a perceived deviation from established lore, a belief that political agendas are overshadowing artistic integrity, or a general aversion to inclusivity within the game’s design. The effect is a polarization of the player base, with supporters defending the game’s representation and critics decrying it as pandering or inauthentic.
The importance of understanding these “woke” accusations lies in recognizing their impact on the game’s reception and the wider debate surrounding representation in media. For example, if a character’s race or sexual orientation is perceived as gratuitous or implemented solely for representation’s sake, it is more likely to draw criticism and be labeled “woke.” Conversely, if these elements are integrated seamlessly into the narrative and contribute to the character’s depth and development, they are more likely to be accepted or even praised. Furthermore, the “woke” accusations often reflect broader societal tensions surrounding identity politics and cultural values, making the discussion extend beyond the confines of the game itself. The practical significance of this understanding lies in the ability to analyze and contextualize the criticisms, identify the underlying concerns, and potentially bridge the divide between opposing viewpoints.
In summary, “woke” accusations are a central aspect of the “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” phenomenon. They reflect a complex interplay of factors, including perceived narrative choices, character representation, and broader societal debates. Successfully navigating these accusations requires a nuanced understanding of their origins, motivations, and potential consequences. By examining the specific criticisms leveled against Dragon Age: The Veilguard and the responses they elicit, it becomes possible to gain valuable insights into the evolving landscape of representation in video games and the challenges associated with creating inclusive and engaging entertainment experiences.
5. Representation Debate
The “representation debate,” concerning the portrayal of diverse characters and themes in media, is intrinsically linked to “dragon age veilguard woke reddit.” The upcoming release of Dragon Age: The Veilguard has ignited discussions on the authenticity, scope, and impact of representation within the game, mirroring broader societal conversations about inclusivity and cultural sensitivity. These discussions are amplified and scrutinized on platforms like Reddit, solidifying the connection between the game’s representation choices and the ensuing community reactions.
-
Authenticity of Portrayals
The debate often centers on whether the representation of diverse characters feels authentic and nuanced, or contrived and stereotypical. For instance, a character’s racial background should ideally inform their experiences and perspectives without reducing them to a caricature. Within the context of “dragon age veilguard woke reddit,” users examine if BioWare’s character designs and narratives genuinely reflect the lived experiences of the groups they aim to represent, or if they fall into harmful tropes.
-
Scope of Inclusivity
The discussion extends to the breadth of representation, including race, ethnicity, gender identity, sexual orientation, and disability. The absence or underrepresentation of certain groups can be perceived as exclusionary, leading to criticism. The ‘dragon age veilguard woke reddit’ discussions often analyze if The Veilguard offers a comprehensive and equitable representation of the diverse populations within its fantasy world.
-
Impact on Narrative and Gameplay
The debate considers how representation is integrated into the game’s narrative and gameplay mechanics. Tokenistic representation, where diverse characters are included without meaningful roles or development, is often criticized. Ideally, representation should enrich the narrative and provide players with opportunities to explore different perspectives and experiences. On Reddit, users frequently debate whether the inclusive elements enhance the overall gaming experience or detract from the core gameplay.
-
Balancing Representation with Artistic Vision
A critical aspect of the debate involves balancing the desire for accurate and inclusive representation with the creative freedom of the developers. Some argue that imposing strict representation guidelines can stifle artistic expression, while others maintain that inclusivity is a moral imperative. Within “dragon age veilguard woke reddit,” discussions often grapple with finding a middle ground, exploring how BioWare can incorporate diverse characters and themes without sacrificing its artistic integrity.
The multifaceted nature of the representation debate directly fuels the conversations within “dragon age veilguard woke reddit.” The authenticity, scope, narrative integration, and balance with artistic vision all contribute to the complex and often contentious discussions surrounding Dragon Age: The Veilguard‘s approach to representation. Analyzing these facets provides a deeper understanding of the underlying concerns and expectations that shape the community’s reaction to the game’s portrayal of diversity.
6. Developer Intent
The concept of “Developer Intent” holds considerable significance within the context of “dragon age veilguard woke reddit.” The perceived motivations and goals of BioWare in designing Dragon Age: The Veilguard, particularly with respect to inclusivity and representation, heavily influence the nature and tone of discussions on Reddit. The community’s interpretation of the developer’s purpose shapes their evaluation of the game’s merit and authenticity.
-
Genuine Representation vs. Marketing Strategy
A primary facet of developer intent concerns whether inclusive elements are implemented out of a genuine desire for diverse representation or as a calculated marketing strategy aimed at appealing to specific demographics. If players perceive the representation as authentic and meaningful, it is more likely to be positively received. However, if it is viewed as a cynical attempt to capitalize on social trends, it can fuel accusations of pandering and insincerity. The “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” discourse often involves scrutinizing character backstories, narrative arcs, and marketing materials to discern the underlying intent. For instance, if a character’s identity is prominently featured in promotional content but minimally explored within the game itself, it can lead to suspicion and criticism.
-
Artistic Vision vs. Social Commentary
Another critical aspect revolves around the balance between artistic vision and social commentary. Developers must navigate the delicate task of incorporating relevant social issues into the game’s narrative without sacrificing the integrity of the story or the player’s enjoyment. If the social commentary is perceived as heavy-handed or preachy, it can alienate players who feel that their entertainment is being politicized. The “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” conversations often revolve around whether BioWare has successfully integrated social commentary in a way that enhances the game’s themes and characters, or whether it feels forced and detracts from the overall experience. Examples could include storylines tackling prejudice or discrimination, where the execution determines whether it sparks meaningful reflection or triggers accusations of being “woke.”
-
Internal Diversity and Consultation
The internal composition of the development team and the extent to which they consult with diverse communities can significantly impact the authenticity of the representation. If the development team lacks diversity or fails to engage with relevant cultural consultants, it is more likely to produce portrayals that are insensitive or stereotypical. On Reddit, users may scrutinize the development team’s track record, examining past games for instances of misrepresentation or cultural appropriation. Information about BioWare’s efforts to promote internal diversity and consult with relevant experts can either bolster or undermine confidence in their approach. A lack of transparency in this area can breed suspicion and contribute to negative sentiment.
-
Responding to Feedback and Criticism
The developer’s response to feedback and criticism from the community plays a crucial role in shaping the overall perception of their intent. A willingness to listen to constructive criticism, acknowledge mistakes, and make adjustments can demonstrate a genuine commitment to inclusivity and representation. Conversely, dismissive or defensive responses can reinforce negative perceptions and fuel further backlash. The “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” discourse often tracks BioWare’s responses to community concerns, analyzing their tone, substance, and impact on player sentiment. Active engagement and demonstrable changes based on community feedback can mitigate negative perceptions and foster a more positive dialogue.
In conclusion, the perceived developer intent is a pivotal element shaping the “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” phenomenon. The community’s assessment of BioWare’s motivations, methods, and responsiveness significantly influences their evaluation of the game’s inclusivity and overall quality. By scrutinizing the game’s content, marketing materials, and developer communication, players attempt to discern the true intent behind the game’s design, ultimately impacting its reception and legacy.
7. Community Division
The dynamic of community division is an inherent aspect of the “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” phenomenon. Discussions surrounding Dragon Age: The Veilguard‘s perceived “woke” elements frequently lead to starkly contrasting viewpoints within the fanbase, resulting in fragmented opinions and, at times, hostile interactions. This division stems from varying perspectives on representation, social commentary, and the role of politics in gaming. The effect is a discernible split, with one faction supporting the game’s inclusive features and another criticizing them as forced or detrimental to the franchise. The intensity of this division is amplified by the anonymity and echo chambers often found on Reddit, where users can selectively engage with viewpoints that reinforce their existing beliefs. For example, positive sentiment might dominate one subreddit while another forum experiences primarily negative critique, exacerbating the sense of discord within the overall Dragon Age community.
The importance of understanding community division within the “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” context lies in its potential impact on the game’s long-term success and the overall health of the fan base. Severe division can lead to boycotts, negative reviews, and a decline in player engagement. Conversely, a more unified community fosters a positive atmosphere, encourages constructive dialogue, and strengthens the franchise’s longevity. The practical significance of this understanding extends to BioWare’s ability to manage community expectations, address concerns, and potentially bridge the divide through clear communication and thoughtful design choices. For instance, actively engaging with Reddit discussions, providing context for design decisions, and demonstrating a willingness to incorporate feedback could help mitigate some of the animosity and foster a more inclusive environment. Ignoring or dismissing community concerns, however, risks further alienating segments of the fan base and exacerbating existing tensions.
In conclusion, community division is an unavoidable consequence of the “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” discourse. It highlights the complex interplay between representation, social commentary, and the expectations of a diverse player base. Addressing this division requires careful consideration of developer intent, transparent communication, and a genuine commitment to fostering a respectful and inclusive community. The challenge lies in finding a balance between artistic vision and community expectations, ensuring that Dragon Age: The Veilguard appeals to a broad audience without compromising its creative integrity or alienating significant portions of its fan base. The ability to navigate this complex terrain will ultimately determine the game’s lasting impact and the future of the Dragon Age franchise.
8. Cultural Commentary
The intersection of Dragon Age: The Veilguard and Reddit’s discussions under the umbrella of “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” forms a microcosm of larger cultural conversations. The game’s themes, character representations, and narrative choices serve as a canvas onto which societal values, anxieties, and debates are projected. Thus, analysis necessitates considering the game not only as entertainment but as a reflection of contemporary cultural currents.
-
Reflection of Societal Values
Dragon Age: The Veilguard, through its diverse cast and exploration of social issues, mirrors evolving societal values concerning inclusivity, equality, and social justice. The game’s portrayal of LGBTQ+ relationships, discussions of racial prejudice, and explorations of gender identity reflect growing awareness and acceptance within mainstream culture. The “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” dialogues function as a barometer of how these values are received, debated, and internalized by different segments of the gaming community. For instance, the degree to which players embrace or reject a same-sex romance option can indicate broader societal attitudes towards LGBTQ+ acceptance. Similarly, the reaction to characters of color or individuals with disabilities reflects prevailing views on representation and inclusivity.
-
Examination of Social Issues
The game’s narrative often grapples with complex social issues such as political corruption, economic inequality, and religious extremism. These themes resonate with real-world concerns and provide a framework for players to engage with these issues in a fictional setting. The “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” discussions provide a platform for analyzing the game’s portrayal of these issues, assessing its accuracy, nuance, and potential impact on player perspectives. For example, discussions might center on whether the game’s depiction of a corrupt political system accurately reflects the complexities of real-world governance or whether it oversimplifies the issues for dramatic effect. The value lies in recognizing that games can act as vehicles for social commentary, prompting players to reflect on their own beliefs and values.
-
Critique of Power Structures
Dragon Age: The Veilguard, like many fantasy narratives, often critiques existing power structures, including monarchies, religious institutions, and social hierarchies. The game may challenge traditional notions of authority, explore the consequences of unchecked power, and advocate for social change. The “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” discussions often involve analyzing the game’s critique of power structures, assessing its effectiveness in promoting critical thinking and challenging societal norms. For example, users might discuss whether the game’s portrayal of a tyrannical ruler is a compelling commentary on the dangers of authoritarianism or whether it relies on simplistic stereotypes. The engagement illustrates how games can function as subversive tools, prompting players to question the status quo and envision alternative social arrangements.
-
Exploration of Identity and Belonging
The game’s characters often grapple with questions of identity, belonging, and cultural identity. Players may encounter characters who struggle to reconcile their personal beliefs with societal expectations, navigate conflicting cultural identities, or search for a sense of community. The “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” dialogues provide a space for players to share their own experiences with identity and belonging, connecting with characters who resonate with their personal struggles. The discussions around a character who is ostracized for their cultural background exemplifies this. It reflects a powerful ability of gaming to serve as a mirror, allowing players to see themselves reflected in the game’s narratives and characters.
These facets demonstrate that the intersection of Dragon Age: The Veilguard and the “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” discussions extends far beyond mere entertainment. It represents a significant engagement with contemporary cultural issues, values, and debates. The game serves as a catalyst for reflection, discussion, and ultimately, a deeper understanding of the complex social and cultural landscape we inhabit. By analyzing the game’s content and the community’s reaction to it, valuable insights can be gained into the evolving dynamics of identity, power, and social justice within society.
Frequently Asked Questions
This section addresses common questions arising from discussions surrounding Dragon Age: The Veilguard and its reception on Reddit, particularly concerning accusations of incorporating “woke” elements.
Question 1: What is meant by the phrase “dragon age veilguard woke reddit”?
The phrase refers to discussions and debates taking place on Reddit regarding the upcoming Dragon Age: The Veilguard game, specifically focusing on concerns or criticisms that the game incorporates “woke” themes or elements. These discussions often involve character representation, narrative choices, and perceived social or political messaging.
Question 2: What specific aspects of Dragon Age: The Veilguard are drawing criticism?
Criticism commonly centers on perceived forced diversity, narratives that overly emphasize social justice themes, and deviations from established lore. Concerns are often raised that the game’s focus has shifted from engaging storytelling to promoting specific political ideologies.
Question 3: Is all feedback regarding “woke” elements negative?
No. While some users express concern about what they perceive as excessive political correctness, others praise the game for its inclusivity and diverse representation. Discussions often involve a wide range of opinions and perspectives.
Question 4: How does Reddit amplify these discussions?
Reddit provides a platform for both positive and negative feedback, often creating echo chambers where users primarily interact with like-minded individuals. The upvote/downvote system and subreddit structures can intensify existing divisions and contribute to the spread of misinformation or biased opinions.
Question 5: How does the developer’s intent factor into the “woke” accusations?
The perceived motivations of BioWare significantly influence community perception. If players believe that inclusivity is genuine and serves the narrative, it is more likely to be positively received. However, if it is viewed as a marketing tactic or forced agenda, it can fuel negative sentiment.
Question 6: What impact can these discussions have on the game’s success?
The online discourse can influence public perception, pre-order sales, and overall player engagement. Negative sentiment can lead to boycotts and critical reviews, while positive reception can generate excitement and boost the game’s popularity. The developer’s response to community feedback is crucial in shaping the game’s long-term reception.
In summary, the discussions surrounding Dragon Age: The Veilguard on Reddit represent a complex interplay of diverse viewpoints and evolving societal values. Analyzing these discussions is important for understanding the challenges of representation in modern media.
The next section will address the historical context of similar representation debates in gaming.
Navigating “Dragon Age Veilguard Woke Reddit” Discussions
Engaging with discussions related to “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” requires a nuanced approach. The following tips aim to facilitate informed and constructive participation.
Tip 1: Acknowledge Diverse Perspectives: Recognize that opinions on representation and inclusivity vary widely. Avoid generalizations and engage with individual arguments rather than broad stereotypes.
Tip 2: Examine Source Material: Base arguments on verifiable information about the game. Refer to official trailers, developer statements, and gameplay footage. Avoid relying solely on hearsay or secondhand accounts.
Tip 3: Contextualize Criticisms: When analyzing criticisms of “woke” elements, consider the commenter’s motivations and potential biases. Evaluate arguments based on their merit, not their perceived political alignment.
Tip 4: Engage Respectfully: Maintain a civil tone, even when disagreeing. Avoid personal attacks and inflammatory language. Focus on critiquing ideas rather than individuals.
Tip 5: Understand the Nuances of Representation: Recognize that effective representation requires more than simply including diverse characters. Consider the depth of character development, the integration of their identities into the narrative, and the avoidance of harmful stereotypes.
Tip 6: Differentiate Intent from Impact: Recognize that developer intent does not negate the impact of their choices. Acknowledge that even well-intentioned representation can be flawed or insensitive.
Tip 7: Seek Out Multiple Viewpoints: Actively seek out perspectives that differ from one’s own. Engage with a variety of subreddits and online communities to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the discussions.
These tips emphasize the importance of informed, respectful, and nuanced engagement with discussions surrounding “dragon age veilguard woke reddit.” By adhering to these principles, participants can contribute to a more constructive and productive dialogue.
The subsequent section will summarize the key themes and arguments presented within this analysis.
Conclusion
The multifaceted discussions encapsulated by “dragon age veilguard woke reddit” reveal a complex interplay of factors influencing the reception of Dragon Age: The Veilguard. These factors encompass the game’s character diversity, narrative inclusivity, perceived developer intent, and the dynamics of community interaction on Reddit. The presence of “woke” accusations underscores broader societal tensions concerning representation, identity politics, and the role of social commentary in entertainment. Analysis of the Reddit discourse demonstrates how gaming serves as a platform for exploring and debating contemporary cultural values.
The ongoing dialogue surrounding Dragon Age: The Veilguard highlights the increasing importance of thoughtful and authentic representation in media. As developers navigate the evolving landscape of audience expectations, fostering open communication, understanding diverse perspectives, and prioritizing genuine inclusivity will prove crucial. The reception of this game may serve as a bellwether for future projects, underscoring the power of community engagement and the potential impact of representation choices on the long-term success of entertainment franchises. Continued engagement with these complex issues is essential for shaping a more inclusive and representative future for gaming and media as a whole.
